Warning Signs When Hiring an Automation Consultant
Not all automation consultants deliver on their promises. Some overpromise and underdeliver, while others lack the expertise for complex projects. Here are the red flags to watch for when evaluating automation partners—and how to protect yourself.
Red Flag #1: Quotes Without Discovery
The Warning: They provide a detailed quote after a 15-minute call without understanding your systems, processes, or requirements.
Why It's a Problem: Accurate pricing requires understanding complexity. Quick quotes either mean they're padding for unknowns or they'll hit you with change orders later.
What Good Looks Like: Discovery process (1-3 hours) before quoting, with written scope document.
Red Flag #2: "We Can Do Everything"
The Warning: They claim expertise in every platform, every industry, every type of automation.
Why It's a Problem: True expertise requires focus. Generalists often deliver mediocre results across the board.
What Good Looks Like: Clear specialization (specific platforms or industries) with honest acknowledgment of limitations.
Red Flag #3: No Portfolio or References
The Warning: They can't show examples of past work or provide references to contact.
Why It's a Problem: Either they're new (risky for you) or past clients weren't happy enough to recommend them.
What Good Looks Like: Case studies, portfolio examples, and references you can actually call.
Red Flag #4: Vague on Process
The Warning: They can't clearly explain how they work—phases, milestones, testing, handoff.
Why It's a Problem: Without a process, projects drift, miscommunication happens, and deliverables suffer.
What Good Looks Like: Clear phases, defined milestones, testing procedures, and documentation standards.
Red Flag #5: Pressure Tactics
The Warning: "This price is only good for 24 hours" or "We're almost fully booked, act now."
Why It's a Problem: Legitimate consultants don't need high-pressure sales tactics. Urgency is usually manufactured.
What Good Looks Like: Patient consultation, willingness to answer questions, no artificial deadlines.
Red Flag #6: Guaranteed Results
The Warning: "Guaranteed 500% ROI" or "We promise you'll save 40 hours per week."
Why It's a Problem: Results depend on many factors outside the consultant's control. Honest projections include ranges and assumptions.
What Good Looks Like: Realistic projections with clear assumptions, examples from similar past projects.
Red Flag #7: No Written Agreement
The Warning: They want to start work without a written scope, contract, or terms.
Why It's a Problem: Without written agreement, disputes become he-said-she-said situations.
What Good Looks Like: Written scope of work, clear deliverables, defined terms, and payment milestones.
Red Flag #8: Poor Communication
The Warning: Slow response to initial inquiries, missed meetings, unclear answers to questions.
Why It's a Problem: Communication during sales is usually their best behavior. It only gets worse once you've paid.
What Good Looks Like: Responsive communication, clear answers, punctual meetings.
Red Flag #9: Proprietary Lock-In
The Warning: They want to build on proprietary tools you can only access through them.
Why It's a Problem: You become dependent on them forever. If the relationship ends, you lose your automations.
What Good Looks Like: Building on standard platforms (n8n, Make, Zapier) with full access and documentation for you.
Red Flag #10: No Maintenance Discussion
The Warning: They only talk about building, never about ongoing support and maintenance.
Why It's a Problem: Automation requires ongoing maintenance. APIs change, platforms update, business needs evolve.
What Good Looks Like: Clear discussion of post-launch support options and costs.
Protecting Yourself
Before Signing:
- Get everything in writing (scope, timeline, cost, terms)
- Check references (actually call them)
- Review their portfolio for relevant experience
- Understand who will do the actual work
- Clarify ownership of deliverables
During the Project:
- Require regular progress updates
- Get access to systems from day one
- Review deliverables at each milestone
- Document issues and concerns immediately
Payment Structure:
- Avoid 100% upfront payment
- Tie payments to milestones
- Withhold final payment until deliverables are accepted
Questions to Ask
- Can you show me similar projects you've completed?
- What's your process from start to finish?
- Who specifically will work on my project?
- What happens if something doesn't work as planned?
- How do you handle scope changes?
- What's included in post-launch support?
- Can I speak with a recent client reference?
We Welcome Your Questions
At our automation agency, we encourage thorough evaluation. We're happy to provide references, show our work, and answer any questions.
Contact us for a transparent conversation about your automation needs.
0 comments